Naomi feels like a born loser, both in career and romance. She's already on her second career, and her friends are sure she'll fail again. But Naomi knows she can't quit and packs her bags to head out east to work in an Amish bakery. As Naomi struggles with the culture shock of the Amish life, Lyle finds himself falling for her. And Naomi is drawn to the unexpected soft side of the silent giant but keeps him at arm's length nonetheless. But when an emergency hits the small town, alliances must be formed...and Naomi's independent streak could cost her everything.